SPLC: Atlanta court judges prejudice, unfair in immigration case - CBS46 News

SPLC: Atlanta court judges prejudice, unfair in immigration cases

Posted: Updated:
ATLANTA (CBS46) -

The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) and Emory University’s School of Law found that Atlanta Immigration Court judges have been consistently failing to uphold ethical and legal standards for immigrant detainees.

The information released on Thursday, which was also forwarded to the Director of the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) at the U.S. Department of Justice, Juan P. Osuna, was compiled through observing courts throughout the fall of 2016.

According to the study, Atlanta’s Immigration Judges (IJs) have been accused of bullying children, victims of domestic abuse and asylum seekers. Immigration attorneys also complained that judges imposed standards impossible for an immigrant to meet. (The Atlanta Immigration Court has the lowest approval rate for asylum seekers in the nation--roughly 2 percent, compared to 84 percent in New York City.)

Key areas of concern

The study outlined seven areas of observed ethical misconduct and concluded with recommendations to “promote public confidence and avoid impropriety” throughout proceedings.

Observers found that Atlanta IJs made prejudicial statements and expressed disinterest toward respondents. They often denied bond to immigration detainees and set bonds at unreasonably high amounts. (The national average for immigration bonds in 2015 was $8200, while the average at a detention center whose bonds are set by the Atlanta Immigration Court was about $11,600—41 percent higher.)

Atlanta IJs routinely canceled hearings with little notice to respondents, occasionally prohibited observers in their courtrooms—immigration courts are open to the public—and often referred to detainees as “prisoners.” Most detention facilities require detainees to wear jumpsuits, and the U.S. Supreme Court treats restraints as a measure of last resort in criminal hearings. (The study suggested that the appearance of immigrants wearing unnecessary physical restraints creates a bias, and that some who were shackled could not move enough to sign their names on documents.)

Court interpreters regularly failed to interpret all English language conversations during hearings, and in some instances, the Atlanta Immigration Court continued proceedings without having available interpreters who could speak a respondent’s language. (Immigration Courts are required to provide interpreters—free of charge—for respondents unable to “fully understand and participate in removal proceedings,” according to the Immigration Court Practice Manual.)

The study also noted incidents where Atlanta IJs actively disregarded legal arguments presented in hearings.

Recommendations for immigration judiciaries

The study listed six general recommendations for how the EOIR could address observed misconduct. It requested monitoring Atlanta IJs during immigration court proceedings and recording them whenever they’re present in the courtroom.

It also called for an investigation of the frequent cancellation of Atlanta immigration hearings. (The study noted that the unexpected cancellation of hearings delays proceedings and often increases the cost of representation for respondents and paid attorneys.)

High-quality interpretation in the Atlanta Immigration Court—and an investigation into their failure to provide adequate interpretation in non-Spanish foreign languages—was also requested.

The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) states that it’s currently awaiting a response from the Executive Office for Immigration Review.

The SPLC also publishes general information and profiles of people who have been affected by immigration raids and detained throughout the southeast.

Story written by CBS46 Digital Content Producer Chris Price.

Copyright 2017 WGCL-TV (Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.

Connect with CBS46

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Police: Mom arrested after photo shows plastic bag tied over toddler's head

    Police: Mom arrested after photo shows plastic bag tied over toddler's head

    Monday, October 23 2017 9:19 PM EDT2017-10-24 01:19:24 GMT
    The mother allegedly took this photo of her child with a plastic bag over her head. (Provided by North College Hill police)The mother allegedly took this photo of her child with a plastic bag over her head. (Provided by North College Hill police)

    A North College Hill mother faced a judge Monday after police say she tied a brown plastic bag over her 2-year-old daughter's head for a half hour.

    More >

    A North College Hill mother faced a judge Monday after police say she tied a brown plastic bag over her 2-year-old daughter's head for a half hour.

    More >
  • 3 arrested after man was choked to death in Clayton County

    3 arrested after man was choked to death in Clayton County

    Monday, October 23 2017 10:53 PM EDT2017-10-24 02:53:24 GMT
    Courtney (left), Cordelia (center) and Kindall Cherry (Source: Clayton County Sheriff's Office)Courtney (left), Cordelia (center) and Kindall Cherry (Source: Clayton County Sheriff's Office)

    There people were arrested Monday in connection to the choking death of a man in Clayton County.

    More >

    There people were arrested Monday in connection to the choking death of a man in Clayton County.

    More >
  • High school locked down after staff member attempts suicide

    High school locked down after staff member attempts suicide

    Monday, October 23 2017 11:19 PM EDT2017-10-24 03:19:54 GMT
    Towers High School in Decatur was locked down Monday after a staff member attempted to commit suicide. The incident occurred during second period at the high school, according to a letter that was sent to parents from DeKalb County Schools. Officials say the Level 2 Lockdown meant there was no movement in the building. A school social worker and school public safety officials were on-site. Officials say 911 was also called for emergency assistance. The safety and security of stude...More >
    Towers High School in Decatur was locked down Monday after a staff member attempted to commit suicide. The incident occurred during second period at the high school, according to a letter that was sent to parents from DeKalb County Schools. Officials say the Level 2 Lockdown meant there was no movement in the building. A school social worker and school public safety officials were on-site. Officials say 911 was also called for emergency assistance. The safety and security of stude...More >